A PERM audit is not a finding of wrongdoing. It is a request by the Department of Labor for additional documentation or explanations to support the application. But it generally adds months to an already lengthy process and requires the employer to produce detailed records of every recruitment step. Employers who treat documentation as an afterthought are the ones who struggle most when an audit arrives.
Audit selection can be random or targeted. There is no guaranteed way to avoid one — but thorough documentation from the start is the most effective preparation available.
What Triggers a PERM Audit?
The DOL does not publish its audit selection criteria in detail, but audits are known to be triggered by a range of factors, including:
- Wage rates that appear inconsistent with the prevailing wage determination
- Job requirements that seem tailored to a specific candidate rather than genuinely required for the role
- Positions with unusually restrictive or uncommon requirements
- Applications in industries or occupations the DOL has identified for closer scrutiny
- Random selection as part of DOL’s quality assurance process
The most common substantive reason applications face increased scrutiny is overly specific job requirements. If a job description appears designed to match one individual’s resume rather than reflect the genuine needs of the position, the DOL will want to understand why.
What Does an Audit Involve?
When the DOL selects a case for audit, it issues a formal audit letter requesting documentation that typically includes:
- Proof that all required recruitment steps were completed as reported
- Documentation of each applicant considered during the recruitment process and the lawful, job-related reason each was not hired
- Evidence that the employer paid all recruitment and advertising costs
- Documentation supporting any special requirements listed in the application
The employer has a set period — typically 30 days — to respond. Responses should be thorough, and well-organized, and guided by a qualified and licensed attorney. Incomplete or inconsistent documentation is one of the most common reasons audited cases result in denial.
How Long Does an Audit Add to the Timeline?
A PERM application currently averages 15 or more months in standard adjudication. Audited cases typically add a few months beyond that, depending on the complexity of the audit response and the DOL’s review workload. In some cases, audits have extended timelines by several months.
The Most Effective Audit Defense Is Before the Audit
The employers best positioned to respond to a PERM audit are those who, with the guidance of qualified and licensed attorney, maintained rigorous documentation throughout the recruitment process.
This documentation should be organized and retained not just through the PERM filing, but for the duration of the entire green card process and beyond. Please contact our office to discuss best documentation practices.
Job Description Design and Audit Risk
One of the most effective ways to reduce audit risk is to ensure the job description reflects the genuine, minimum requirements for the role — not the qualifications of the foreign national employee. Requirements that are unusual for the occupation, or that mirror the employee’s specific background in ways that are not standard in the industry, will attract DOL scrutiny.
Before recruitment begins, the job description should be reviewed and approved by a qualified and licensed attorney to confirm that it will pass muster. Please contact our office to discuss how to structure a job description.
Responding to an Audit
If an audit letter is received, the employer should call our office immediately. The response must address each item in the audit letter specifically, supported by organized documentation. Generalized or incomplete responses are unlikely to resolve the audit successfully.
Polatsek, Boheme & Wilkowski guides employers through every stage of the PERM process, including audit response and documentation strategy. For an overview of employer obligations and PERM requirements, see PERM Labor Certification at polatsek.law.
Disclaimer: THIS DOCUMENT INCLUDES GENERAL INFORMATION ONLY THAT IS INTENDED TO HELP CONSUMERS LEARN ABOUT THE LAW AND THE LEGAL SYSTEM. IT DOES NOT CONSTITUTE LEGAL ADVICE AND MUST NOT BE RELIED UPON OR USED AS A SUBSTITUTE FOR THE COUNSEL AND SERVICES PROVIDED BY A LICENSED ATTORNEY. VIEWING THIS INFORMATION DOES NOT CREATE AN ATTORNEY-CLIENT RELATIONSHIP. ALL CASES ARE DIFFERENT AND LEGAL ADVICE IS HIGHLY DEPENDENT ON THE PARTICULAR FACTS AND LEGAL ISSUES IN QUESTION. ONLY INDIVIDUAL ATTORNEYS CAN PROVIDE ASSURANCES THAT THE INFORMATION CONTAINED HEREIN, AND YOUR INTERPRETATION OF IT, IS APPLICABLE AND APPROPRIATE TO YOUR SPECIFIC SITUATION. YOU SHOULD REFRAIN FROM ACTING ON THE BASIS OF THIS INFORMATION ALONE WITHOUT SEEKING LEGAL ADVICE FROM A QUALIFIED ATTORNEY. RELIANCE AND USE OF THE INFORMATION CONTAINED HEREIN IS DONE AT YOUR OWN RISK.
IF YOU WOULD LIKE LEGAL ADVICE, PLEASE CONTACT OUR OFFICE TO SCHEDULE A CONSULTATION.
